Wednesday, September 30, 2009

SEPTEMBER 29, 2009 -- MINNESOTA 3-5, DETROIT 2-6

The Twins and Tigers split the twinbill that was prompted by Monday's rain showers, and unfortunately the Twins open play on Wednesday in exactly the same position that they did on Tuesday. Frankly the Twins were lucky to get a split, as they nearly lost the first game all by themselves (namely Mr. Nick Punto). It's ironic that the play from guys like Tolbert and Punto have not been May-esque, i.e. they haven't been losing games consistently like they've done most of the season (or their careers for that matter). What's worse is that this two week stretch of decent play from these guys has made Ron Gardenhire believe that they can be trusted in huge situations. When the season's on the line, Nick Punto will show his true colors, and that wasn't more evident in the ninth inning of the first game, when his suicide squeeze turned out to be one of the most pathetic "ploys" by a "contending" team I've ever seen. It failed miserably for Gardy and company, and if not for a great catch by Denard Span in the bottom of the ninth, the Twins wouldn't have had the opportunity to win it in extra frames.

And then the nightcap, where Brian Duensing reverted back to his Douchebag status, at least for 4 and 2/3 innings, when he graciously put the team in a 5-0 hole. The Twins clawed back, getting back to 5-4 against Tigers ace Justin Verlander, but still could not afford the big hit in the big situation. Jim Leyland, to his credit, kept his ace pitcher in for the pressure situations. For the second time this month, he let Verlander pitch into the eighth inning against the Twins when his pitch count was over 120, something that Ron Gardenhire would probably have a heart attack just thinking about. Verlander got the strikeouts in the clutch situations, and certainly deserved to win. The game was still within reach, however, until Matty Guerrier came in to "hold the fort" down in the eighth, and he gave up that oh-so-important insurance run compliments of a Curtis Granderson home run. Sure enough, the Twins rally to get one run in the top of the ninth (ironically, on a fly ball Granderson misplayed for a double). Guerrier hasn't pitched much of late and the least he can do is get three guys out to protect a one-run deficit. But we all know that Guerrier late in the season loves to suck, so this was a fitting performance from a terrible reliever.

I'm not willing to forget that ninth inning quickly, either, when Ron Gardenhire, in his infinite wisdom, allowed Tolbert and Punto to hit for themselves against Tiger closer Fernando Rodney. Punto was up there and his fly ball to Granderson was nothing more than a medium-deep drive to center that Granderson misplayed. In other words, Gardenhire was willing to end the game with Nick Punto at the plate. Yeah, both players have been playing better and they're no longer flirting with the Mendoza Line. But the fact remains is that both players are still pathetic excuses for a major league baseball player. Tolbert's hitting a paltry .223, and Punto's .232 average is certainly peckish. You've got guys on the bench that, while they're not all that great (Buscher and Harris come to mind immediately), they're not in the league of futility that those to "ballplayers" belong in. But if you ask Ron Gardenhire, I guarantee he'll tell you that a major reason the Twins have gotten back in the race is because of Punto and Tolbert hitting "like they're capable of." This is who we're dealing with, people. A man who has faith in Nick Punto.

The Twins get to face the Tigers' version of Douchebag (or would it be Manship?) in Eddie Bonine tonight, but let's not forget that Bonine took a no-hitter into the sixth inning in his last start against the White Sox before finally giving up a few runs. Carl Pavano's been great against the Tigers this year, and expect Dick Bremer to mention that about fifteen times before 6:30. For all intents and purposes, the Twins need to win the last two games to have a realistic shot at the division. Something tells me that this has all been one big tease.
Photos: (1) AP/Paul Sancya; (2,3) AP/Duane Burleson

4 comments:

Yawn Gardenhose said...

I had to follow the 1st game on SI.com and just about destroyed my computer when I saw that Punto bunted into a double play. But when you look at the highlights it was a tough pitch to bunt and he had to at least make an effort. The blame for that has to be directed at Gardy. What an idiotic thing to do. Why not safety squeeze? Or, better yet, WHY NOT PINCH HIT FOR NICK PUNTO WHEN A SIMPLE FLY BALL WILL GIVE YOU THE LEAD?

Fast forward to Game 2. Top 9, down 2. Gardy pinch-hits not for Tolbert or Punto but Gomez. Now, Gomez isn't a great hitter, but with his speed can maybe beat out a dribbler. Instead Gardy rides it out with the 4th string 3rd basement and his high school crush Nicky P. with completely predictable results (Granderson's gaffe does not let Punto off the hook).

Closed circuit to Gardy: if Nick Punto comes up again in the 9th inning in any of the remaining games this year, PINCH HIT FOR HIM. For the love of God, after coming this far don't blow the season on another Punto failure.

TP in the TC said...

Two things you failed to point out about game 2.
1) In the fifth Duensing walked the first batter, who advanced on a sac, then he intentionally walked Cabrera and pitched around Thames; all meaning HE DIDN'T GIVE UP A HIT. Gardy is the real Douchbag for taking the kid out instead of letting him work through this and putting in Keppel who was an automatic two run base hit.
2) Why didn't Mijares pitch against Granderson in the 8th? Is it because Granderson hits less than .200 against lefties? There was no excuse for that whatsoever.

Eisenhower McSteele said...

TP --

Props on pointing those out. Having to list all the ways that Gardy f***ed up Game 2 is tedious to say the least. More often than not it's those last pathetic decisions (e.g. Tuesday, letting Tolbert and Punto hit in the ninth) that really stand out. "50 Ways Ron Gardenhire Screwed Up Tuesday" sounds like a bad Paul Simon song.

Thanks for the post.

Yawn Gardenhose said...

Yeah I'm sure Gardy's justification for not pinch hitting for Tolbert and Punto is that they are lefties going against a righty in Rodney. Which makes it all the more baffling that he trotted out Guerrier against Granderson. It's like he gets so nervous or tightly-wound that he can't even be consistent in his strategic mismanagement of big games.